The Apple Watch resale market has transformed dramatically, with trade-in values reaching up to $175 for damaged models, according to SellCell's latest market data. For those wondering how to maximize value from a broken Apple Watch, there are now multiple specialized buyback services that offer competitive rates even for damaged devices. As explored in our complete guide to selling broken electronics and detailed Apple Watch selling guide, you can still recover significant value from these devices. Let's explore the best options!
Jump to
Summary Table
| Item Name | Price Range | Best For | Website |
|---|---|---|---|
| SellCell | $50-$175 | Price Comparison | Visit Site |
| SmartphonesPLUS | $45-$160 | Quick Payment | Visit Site |
| PayMore | $40-$150 | In-Store Sales | Visit Site |
| BankMyCell | $35-$165 | Multiple Offers | Visit Site |
| Apple Trade | $25-$155 | Store Credit | Visit Site |
| Verizon Trade | $30-$145 | Bill Credits | Visit Site |
Key Information
Below you'll find detailed information about each aspect, including important details and considerations.
1. SellCell
Compare multiple buyers' offers for your broken Apple Watch in one place, helping you get the best possible price for damaged devices. SellCell aggregates quotes from trusted electronics buyers across the US, streamlining the selling process through their price comparison platform.
Key benefits:
- Instant price comparisons from multiple buyers
- Free shipping with most buyers
- Payment typically within 48 hours of device receipt
Trade in your non-functioning Apple Watch through SmartphonesPLUS's straightforward online process. This buyer accepts damaged watches from all series and provides competitive offers based on model and condition assessment. Learn more about maximizing your broken device's value in our Complete Guide to Selling Broken Electronics.
What to expect:
- Quick online quotes for damaged devices
- Free shipping kit provided
- Payment sent within 24 hours of inspection
3. PayMore
Get immediate cash offers for your damaged Apple Watch through PayMore's network of physical store locations. Their in-person evaluation process means you can walk out with payment the same day, while their secure data wiping services ensure your personal information is protected.
Store features:
- Same-day cash payments
- Professional device assessment
- Certified data removal included
4. BankMyCell
BankMyCell serves as a price comparison platform specifically designed for selling damaged Apple devices, including broken Apple Watches. The service aggregates offers from multiple buyback vendors, helping you find the highest payout for your non-working smartwatch without checking multiple sites individually.
Key features:
- Compare up to 30+ buyback vendors instantly
- Price lock guarantee for 14-30 days
- Free shipping with most vendors
5. Apple Trade
Apple's official trade-in program accepts damaged Apple Watches, offering store credit or gift cards even for devices with cracked screens or battery issues. While they won't take completely destroyed watches, they'll accept most functional but damaged devices and provide free recycling for non-qualifying items. Learn more about maximizing trade-in value in our complete guide to selling broken Apple Watches.
What you get:
- Instant store credit for qualifying devices
- Free shipping and eco-friendly recycling
- Secure data wiping included
Verizon's trade-in program accepts damaged Apple Watches from both existing customers and non-customers alike. The service offers competitive credit amounts that can be applied toward new device purchases or monthly bill credits, making it particularly valuable if you're planning to upgrade through Verizon.
Notable perks:
- Instant credit assessment online
- Additional bonus credit during promotional periods
- Accepts devices with cracked screens or battery issues
Final Words
Whether your Apple Watch has a cracked screen or won't power on, you have multiple reliable options to sell it and recover some value, with potential payouts ranging from $25 for severely damaged models to $200+ for newer watches with minor issues. Choose the selling method that best matches your priorities - whether that's getting the highest price (direct buyers), fastest sale (trade-in programs), or most convenient process (online buyback sites) - and be sure to compare offers from multiple buyers before accepting any deal.