Physical video game sales in North America remain a multi-billion dollar market, per Statista, and a growing secondary market means your used games hold real resale value right now. Whether you're clearing shelf space or turning a collection into cash, knowing where to sell makes all the difference — trade-in stores, specialty buyers, and peer-to-peer platforms all offer different payouts. Like selling used items for cash, the best platform depends on speed, convenience, and how much you want to earn. Ready to get started?
Quick Answer
You can sell video games at GameStop, specialty stores like Decluttr, or peer-to-peer platforms like eBay and Facebook Marketplace. Trade-in stores offer instant cash but lower payouts, while online platforms typically yield more. Choose based on speed versus profit — local buyers pay fast, online selling maximizes value.
Jump to
Summary Table
| Item Name | Price Range | Best For | Website |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify | $19–25/month | E-commerce Entrepreneurs | Visit Site |
| eStarland | $1–$50+ per game | Online Trade-In Sellers | Visit Site |
| Game X Change | $1–$40 per game | In-Store Cash Sellers | Visit Site |
| PayMore | $2–$50 per game | Quick Local Cash | Visit Site |
| Lukie Games | $1–$60 per game | Retro & Classic Game Sellers | Visit Site |
| JJ Games | $1–$50 per game | Bulk Game Sellers | Visit Site |
| PNP Games | $1–$40 per game | Specialty Trade-In Sellers | Visit Site |
| Video Games Plus Plus | $1–$60 per game | Canadian & International Sellers | Visit Site |
| GameStop | $1–$35 per game | Convenient In-Store Trade-Ins | Visit Site |
| eBay | $5–$200+ per game | Maximum Profit Sellers | Visit Site |
| Mercari | $5–$100 per game | Casual Peer-to-Peer Sellers | Visit Site |
| $5–$150+ per game | Fee-Free Community Selling | See details | |
| Gameflip | $1–$100 per game | Digital & Physical Game Sellers | Visit Site |
Where to Sell Video Games: 13 Best Places (2025)
Below you'll find detailed information about each aspect, including important details and considerations.
1. Shopify
Shopify lets you build your own branded online store to sell video games directly to customers without relying on third-party marketplaces. You keep more profit per sale since there are no per-item listing fees eating into your margins. It's best suited for sellers with an established inventory who want full control over pricing, branding, and customer relationships.
Key details:
- Plans start at $19–25/month with a 3-day free trial
- Built-in payment processing, inventory tracking, and shipping tools
- Best for: Entrepreneurs building a long-term game-selling business
2. eStarland
eStarland is a dedicated video game retailer that buys used games, consoles, and accessories directly from sellers. You can get an instant trade-in quote online, ship your items for free, and receive payment via check or store credit. Store credit typically pays out 10–20% more than cash value, making it a solid option if you plan to buy games through them as well.
What to know:
- Free prepaid shipping label provided after quote acceptance
- Accepts retro and modern titles across most major platforms
- Payment by check or higher-value store credit
Game X Change is a regional used game store chain operating primarily in the southern United States, making it a convenient local option for unloading games without shipping hassles. You bring in your titles, get an on-the-spot offer, and walk out with cash or store credit the same day. It's particularly useful for sellers who prefer face-to-face transactions over mailing items to online buyers.
Quick facts:
- Instant cash or store credit offers — no waiting for payment
- Accepts games, consoles, and accessories across generations
- Best for: Sellers located near a Game X Change storefront
4. PayMore
PayMore is a retail chain that buys used video games, consoles, and electronics directly in-store, making it one of the fastest ways to get cash for your collection without dealing with online listings or shipping. With locations across the US, you can walk in, get an instant quote, and leave with payment the same day. It's ideal for sellers who want a quick, hassle-free transaction rather than waiting for an online buyer.
What to know:
- In-store cash or trade-in credit offered on the spot
- Accepts games, consoles, controllers, and accessories
- No fees, shipping, or waiting for buyers
5. Lukie Games
Lukie Games is a retro-focused online retailer that purchases used classic video games, making it a strong option if your collection includes older titles from NES, SNES, N64, or early PlayStation eras. They buy games outright rather than through auction, so pricing is straightforward. Sellers ship their games in and receive payment after inspection, with no listing fees involved.
What to know:
- Specializes in retro and classic game titles
- Direct buyout model — no auction or bidding
- Payment issued after games are received and verified
6. JJ Games
JJ Games is an online used game buyer that accepts a wide range of titles and platforms, giving sellers a straightforward way to unload their games for cash. You request a quote, ship your games for free, and receive payment once they're processed. It suits sellers looking to move larger lots or mixed collections without sorting through individual marketplaces.
What to know:
- Free shipping label provided for your trade-in
- Accepts games across multiple generations and platforms
- Payment via check or PayPal after inspection
7. PNP Games
PNP Games is a specialty retailer that buys used video games, consoles, and accessories, making it a viable option if you prefer selling to a dedicated gaming store rather than a general marketplace. They focus on retro and modern titles, so collectors and casual sellers alike can find buyers for older or niche inventory that mainstream outlets might undervalue.
What to know:
- Accepts a wide range of titles including retro and hard-to-find games
- In-store trade-in process with on-the-spot quotes
- Better fit for niche or older titles than big-box retailers
Video Games Plus Plus is an online store and marketplace focused on buying and selling video games, particularly retro titles and older-generation hardware. If you have classic cartridges or legacy console games collecting dust, this platform connects you with buyers who specifically seek out vintage gaming items rather than just the latest releases.
Key details:
- Specializes in retro and vintage game inventory
- Targets collectors willing to pay fair market value for older titles
- Online-based, so you can list without visiting a physical store
9. GameStop
GameStop is one of the most accessible places to trade in video games, with thousands of physical locations across North America making drop-off quick and convenient. You can walk in with used games and receive store credit or cash on the spot, though cash payouts are typically lower than what you'd earn selling directly to another player. Store credit offers are usually 20–30% higher than cash offers.
Trade-in highlights:
- Cash or store credit options available instantly
- Accepts current-gen and select older-generation titles
- Promotional trade-in bonuses periodically boost payout values
10. eBay
eBay remains one of the most popular places to sell video games online, giving you access to over 130 million active buyers worldwide. You can list games at a fixed price or run auctions, which is especially useful for rare or vintage titles that can fetch well above retail. eBay charges a final value fee of around 13.25% per sale, with 250 free listings per month before insertion fees apply.
Key details:
- Auction format ideal for rare, collectible, or out-of-print games
- Final value fee: ~13.25% of sale price
- Explore top selling platforms if fees feel too high
11. Mercari
Mercari is a straightforward peer-to-peer marketplace where casual sellers can list used video games quickly without needing an established seller account or storefront. It's popular for everyday gaming titles across all console generations and appeals to buyers looking for fair prices. Mercari charges a flat 10% selling fee plus a $2 transfer fee when withdrawing earnings, making it slightly cheaper than eBay for lower-value games.
Key details:
- Flat 10% fee — no listing fees or monthly subscriptions
- Built-in shipping labels simplify the fulfillment process
- Best for: Casual sellers offloading single titles or small collections
12. Reddit
Reddit hosts active communities like r/GameSale and r/retrogaming where you can sell video games directly to other enthusiasts with zero platform fees. Transactions happen peer-to-peer, typically via PayPal Goods & Services, keeping more money in your pocket compared to marketplace alternatives. Buyer trust is built through your account's comment history and trade feedback, so it works best for sellers with an established Reddit presence.
Key details:
- No selling fees — you keep the full agreed price
- r/GameSale and r/retrogaming are the primary communities for gaming trades
13. Gameflip
Gameflip is a dedicated marketplace specifically built for selling video games, making it one of the most targeted platforms for unloading your collection. It supports physical games, digital codes, and in-game items, connecting you directly with buyers who are actively looking to purchase games. Fees run around 8–15% per sale depending on your seller level.
Key details:
- Supports physical games, digital codes, and DLC
- Seller-level system can reduce fees over time
- Built-in buyer/seller rating system for trust
Final Words
Your best bet depends on whether you want fast cash, top dollar, or the convenience of selling locally tips — so match the platform to your priority and start clearing out that collection today.