Where to Sell Board Games: 11 Top Options (2025)

The U.S. board games market is expanding steadily, per IMARC Group, creating real demand for secondhand titles across dozens of platforms. Whether you're clearing shelf space or cashing in on a collection, knowing where to sell makes all the difference — the right platform can net you significantly more than a garage sale. If you also have other collectibles to move, check out our tips on selling comic books for cash or browse the best local selling websites to cover all your bases. Here are 11 of the best places to sell board games right now — let's get started!

Jump to

• Quick Answer
• Summary Table
• Full Listing

Summary Table

Where to Sell Board Games: 11 Top Options (2025)

Below you'll find detailed information about each aspect, including important details and considerations.

1. Shopify

Shopify lets you build a dedicated online store to sell board games directly to customers, keeping full control over pricing, branding, and inventory. Unlike marketplace platforms that take large commissions, you set your own rules. It works equally well for small collections of used games or a full retail operation with new titles.

Key details:

• Plans from $19–$25/month with a 3-day free trial
• Built-in payment processing, shipping tools, and inventory tracking
• Best for: Entrepreneurs building a branded board game shop

2. BoardGameGeek GeekMarket

GeekMarket is the built-in marketplace on BoardGameGeek, the hobby's most-visited community site, making it one of the most targeted places to list used or collectible games. Buyers here are dedicated hobbyists who already know what they want, which means faster sales and less explaining the value of what you're selling.

What to know:

• Free to list; audience is exclusively board game enthusiasts
• Strong trust signals from seller ratings within the BGG community
• Best for: Selling specific titles to knowledgeable collectors

3. eBay

eBay reaches millions of general shoppers and works well for listing out-of-print, rare, or collectible board games that command premium prices at auction. Sellers can choose fixed-price listings or auction format, which is useful when you're unsure of a game's current market value. Fees typically run 10–15% per sale including payment processing.

Notable perks:

• Auction format helps surface true market value for rare titles
• Massive buyer pool beyond dedicated hobby audiences

4. Noble Knight Games

Noble Knight Games is a dedicated buyback and resale platform for tabletop games, making it one of the more straightforward options for unloading your collection directly to a specialty retailer. They purchase used, out-of-print, and new board games outright, so you skip the hassle of listing items and waiting for buyers. Payouts come as store credit (higher value) or cash.

Key details:

• Submit a buylist request at Noble Knight's site to get an offer
• Out-of-print and rare titles typically fetch better offers
• Store credit payouts are roughly 10–20% higher than cash offers

5. Tabletop Junkie

The Tabletop Junkie marketplace is a community-focused platform built specifically for buying and selling used board games peer-to-peer. Because the audience is already interested in tabletop gaming, listings tend to attract serious buyers rather than casual browsers, which can speed up sales on niche or hobby titles.

Notable perks:

• Seller-friendly community with low friction for hobbyist transactions
• Better fit for mid-range and hobby games than general marketplaces
• If you also deal in vintage games, see tips on selling vintage items online

6. BoardGameSeek Marketplace

BoardGameGeek's built-in marketplace (often called BoardGameSeek by the community) lets you list games directly on the world's largest board game database. Since millions of collectors and hobbyists already browse BGG for game information, your listings appear in front of highly targeted buyers who know exactly what they're looking for.

What you get:

• Access to a massive, purchase-ready board game audience
• Listings tied to game database entries for instant buyer context
• No separate storefront needed — integrates with your existing BGG account

7. Local Game Stores

Taking your board games directly to a local game store (LGS) is one of the fastest ways to get cash or store credit without shipping hassles. Many LGS owners actively buy used games, especially popular titles in good condition, and can offer on-the-spot quotes. Store credit typically yields 10–20% more value than cash payouts.

What to know:

• Cash offers usually run 30–50% of resale value; store credit pays more
• Bring complete games — missing pieces significantly reduce offers
• Best for: sellers who want immediate payment and no shipping

8. Reddit r/BoardGameExchange

The r/BoardGameExchange subreddit is a dedicated community where collectors and hobbyists buy, sell, and trade games directly with each other. Listing here puts your games in front of a knowledgeable audience that understands fair market value, reducing lowball offers common on general marketplaces. Sellers set their own prices with no platform fees, though PayPal or similar payment handling applies.

Notable details:

• No listing fees — community-driven with reputation-based trust system
• User flair tracks trade history, building buyer confidence

9. Craigslist

Craigslist lets you list board games for sale locally, connecting you directly with buyers in your area without shipping hassles or platform fees. It works especially well for heavy, large game boxes or complete collections where local pickup makes more sense than mailing. Listings are free in most categories, meaning every dollar goes straight to you.

Key details:

• Free to list in most U.S. cities
• Cash-in-hand transactions — no PayPal disputes or chargebacks
• Best for bulky games or large lots priced $20–$100+

10. Sell Your Toys Now

Sell Your Toys Now is a buyout service that purchases used board games directly from sellers, making it a fast option if you want cash without listing, photographing, or negotiating. You submit your game titles online, receive a quote, ship the items, and get paid — no auction waiting period required. It suits sellers prioritizing convenience over maximizing resale value.

What to expect:

• Instant quote process based on title and condition
• Prepaid shipping label typically provided
• Payout lower than marketplace rates but faster

11. Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is one of the most active platforms for unloading board games locally, giving you access to a massive built-in audience of nearby buyers without listing fees. You can post photos, set your price, and message interested buyers directly through Facebook, making the whole process straightforward. It also supports shipping for wider reach, which helps move harder-to-find or out-of-print titles to collectors nationally.

Notable perks:

• No listing fees for local sales
• Buyer profiles visible, adding a layer of trust
• Shipping option expands reach beyond your city

Final Words

Your best bet depends on whether you want speed, top dollar, or zero hassle — so match the platform to your priority. For broader reach beyond the usual suspects, explore alternatives to eBay for sellers to maximize your chances of a great sale.