Online grocery delivery has exploded in recent years, with the market projected to surpass $100 billion by 2026, per OpenPR. Instacart and Shipt dominate this space, but choosing between them depends on where you live, which stores you prefer, and how often you order. If you're already comparing delivery costs, our food delivery cost comparison and guide to best price tracking apps can help you save even more. Here's exactly how these two services stack up so you can pick the right one fast.
Quick Answer
Instacart offers broader store selection (1,400+ retailers) with no membership required, charging $3.99–$7.99 per delivery. Shipt, owned by Target, costs $99/year or $10.99/month with free unlimited deliveries on orders over $35. Shipt suits frequent Target shoppers; Instacart fits those wanting flexible, multi-store access without a subscription commitment.
Jump to
Summary Table
| Item Name | Price Range | Best For | Website |
|---|---|---|---|
| Membership Cost | $99/year or $9.99/month | Frequent shoppers wanting free delivery | See details |
| Coverage and Availability | Free to check | Shoppers in smaller or rural markets | See details |
| Delivery Features | $0 with membership ($3.99–$7.99 without) | Those needing flexible same-day windows | See details |
| Store Partners | Free to browse | Shoppers loyal to specific grocery chains | See details |
| Shopper Ratings | Free feature | Buyers who prioritize order accuracy | See details |
| Scheduling for Shoppers | Free feature (earner side) | Gig workers wanting flexible hours | See details |
| Tipping | Suggested 5%–20% per order | Shoppers who want transparent tipping | See details |
| Additional Perks | Included with $99/year membership | Target shoppers and loyalty program users | See details |
| Customer Service | Free (included with service) | Shoppers who need reliable issue resolution | See details |
Instacart vs Shipt: Complete Comparison Guide (2026)
Below you'll find detailed information about each option, including what makes them unique and their key benefits.
1. Membership Cost
When comparing these two grocery delivery services, membership pricing is one of the most important factors to evaluate. Instacart+ costs $99/year (or $9.99/month), while Shipt charges $99/year (or $10.99/month). Both waive delivery fees on orders over $35, but Shipt's flat monthly rate is slightly higher, making Instacart+ marginally cheaper for month-to-month subscribers.
Key pricing differences:
- Instacart+: $9.99/month or $99/year
- Shipt: $10.99/month or $99/year
- Both offer free trials (typically 14–30 days)
2. Coverage and Availability
Geographic reach is a decisive factor in the Instacart vs. Shipt debate — one service may simply not operate in your area. Instacart covers over 14,000 store locations across the U.S. and Canada, partnering with 1,400+ retailers. Shipt operates in 5,000+ U.S. cities but has no Canadian presence and focuses primarily on Target, Meijer, and select regional grocers.
Coverage highlights:
- Instacart: Available across U.S. and Canada with broader retailer selection
- Shipt: U.S.-only, with strong Target integration via same-day delivery
- Rural shoppers typically find Instacart more accessible
3. Delivery Features
Delivery speed and flexibility directly affect which service wins for your household's needs. Instacart offers scheduled and same-day delivery windows as fast as one hour, with real-time shopper communication. Shipt similarly delivers same-day but emphasizes a personal shopper model where the same shopper can be requested repeatedly, creating a more consistent experience for regular users.
Notable perks:
- Instacart: 1-hour express delivery available in many markets
- Shipt: Preferred shopper feature for repeat pairings
- Both services waive delivery fees on $35+ orders with membership
4. Store Partners
The retailer networks available through each service is a major deciding factor when comparing these two grocery delivery platforms. Instacart partners with over 1,400 retailers including Costco, Kroger, Aldi, Wegmans, and CVS, giving shoppers access to a wide variety of stores in most markets. Shipt, owned by Target, primarily serves Target orders but also partners with Meijer, H-E-B, Petco, and select regional grocers.
Key differences:
- Instacart: 1,400+ retail partners across grocery, pharmacy, and specialty stores
- Shipt: Fewer partners, but deeper Target integration with same-day availability
- Shipt's store selection varies significantly by region
5. Shopper Ratings
Both platforms use customer rating systems, but how ratings affect shoppers differs between Instacart and Shipt. Instacart uses a 5-star rating system where scores below 4.7 can limit order access or lead to deactivation. Shipt similarly tracks ratings but is considered slightly more forgiving, with shoppers reporting more direct communication options with customers before and during orders.
Rating impact:
- Instacart: 4.7+ stars recommended to maintain full order access
- Shipt: Lower ratings can reduce order visibility but policies are less rigid
- Both platforms allow customers to leave tips alongside star ratings
6. Scheduling for Shoppers
Flexibility in scheduling is a practical comparison point for anyone deciding whether to shop for Instacart or Shipt. Instacart operates on a zone-based system where shoppers claim available batches in real time without pre-scheduling shifts. Shipt uses a more structured scheduling model where shoppers claim specific hour-long windows in advance, which some prefer for predictable income planning.
Schedule structure:
- Instacart: Log in anytime, claim batches on demand — no set shifts required
- Shipt: Claim shifts in advance; preferred windows go fast in busy markets
7. Tipping
Tipping policies differ between these two grocery delivery services and can meaningfully affect your total cost per order. Instacart suggests a default tip of 5% (minimum $2), which you can adjust before or after delivery. Shipt leaves tipping entirely optional with no suggested amount, though shoppers on both platforms rely heavily on tips as part of their earnings.
Key differences:
- Instacart: 5% default tip suggested at checkout
- Shipt: No default tip prompted — fully discretionary
- Both: Tips can be adjusted up to 3 days after delivery
8. Additional Perks
Beyond basic delivery, both platforms offer extras that can tip the scales when deciding which service fits your lifestyle. Instacart provides access to coupons, retailer-specific deals, and a credit card (Instacart Mastercard) offering 5% back on orders. Shipt members at Target can stack Circle loyalty discounts, making it especially valuable for frequent Target shoppers.
Notable perks:
- Instacart: In-app coupons, Mastercard cashback, alcohol delivery at select stores
- Shipt: Target Circle integration, same-day scheduling flexibility
9. Customer Service
When comparing these two delivery platforms, support quality can make or break the experience when orders go wrong. Instacart offers 24/7 live chat and phone support through its app, handling refunds and missing items relatively quickly. Shipt's customer service is also well-regarded, with live chat available and a reputation for responsive, personalized support — partly because members often develop relationships with recurring shoppers.
Support options:
- Instacart: 24/7 chat and phone, automated refund processing
- Shipt: Live chat, email, and community-style shopper relationships
Final Words
Your best bet depends on whether you shop at one store regularly (Shipt) or want flexible multi-retailer access (Instacart). Check out grocery delivery services compared to make the smartest pick for your household.